Erbzine.com Homepage
First and Only Weekly Webzine Devoted to the Life and Works of Edgar Rice Burroughs
Since 1996 ~ Over 15,000 Webpages in Archive
Volume 0759
and
ERB C.H.A.S.E.R ENCYCLOPEDIA
A Collector's Hypertexted and Annotated Storehouse of Encyclopedic Resources
Present
J. Allen St. John: Eternal Lover - sepia FP same as DJ
Large DJ Image
Large Cover Art Image

THE ETERNAL LOVER
Part 1: "The Eternal Lover" working title: "Nu of the Niocene" begun in November 1913 ~ Part 2: Sweetheart Primeval 1914
Read the PD Online Text of this Novel 
HERE


PUBLISHING HISTORY (USA)

PULP
"The Eternal Lover": All-Story Weekly: March 7, 1914
    Modest Stein front cover ~ Fred W. Small B/W headpiece
"Sweetheart Primeval": All-Story Weekly: January 23, 30 & February 6, 13, 1915
    P.J. Monahan cover art on first installment ~ no interiors
Idle Hour Magazine: November & December 1915 ~ first 6 chapters
    Art by unknown artist in November issue
FIRST EDITION
McClurg: "printer's dummy" issued prior to first edition
McClurg: October 3, 1925 ~ 316 pages ~ 1st Ed. Print Run: 5,000 ~ Total: 60,000 ~ Heins word count: 68,000
    J. Allen St. John dust jacket repeated as sepia frontispiece
REPRINT EDITIONS
Grosset & Dunlap: 1927 ~ 316 pages
    J. Allen St. John dust jacket and frontispiece
Grosset & Dunlap: 1940
    J. Allen St. John dust jacket ~ no interiors
The Eternal Savage: Ace paperback: October 1963 and reprint (cover states: Original title: The Eternal Lover) ~ 191 pages
    Roy G. Kenkel cover art and title page
The Eternal Savage: Ace paperback
    Frank Frazetta cover art
Ballantine paperback: November 1992 ~ 201 pages
    Michael Herring cover art
Nebraska Press: Bison Books
 
For detailed information see:Robert Zeuschner's
ERB: The Exhaustive Scholar’s and Collector’s Descriptive Bibliography
Dial 1-800-253-2187 to order a copy from McFarland for $46.50
The Eternal Lover (The Eternal Savage)
While visiting Tarzan in his African jungle home, an American girl falls into the most astonishing science-fiction adventure of all. By a quirk in Time, a white-skinned savage from the Stone Age is thrust forward to modern days long enough to meet her and bring her back to his own world of cave people, saber-tooth tigers, and prehistorical wilderness. The ETERNAL SAVAGE is the story of Nu of the Niocene and Victoria Custer of Nebraska, U.S.A. two human beings pitted against the world of primeval past. A startling natural catastrophe throws a caveman into contact with the modern African jungle a brings a Twentieth Century American girl into the dawn world of the Niocene Age. Here is Nu, son of Nu seeking to test his mettle against the terriblef angs of the ferocious saber-tooth tiger. Here is Victoria Custer, guest of Tarzan, seeking vacation and adventure and finding more than she The Eternal Savage could ever have dreamed of.


COVER GALLERY

Pulp Covers
From the Illustrated ERB Pulp Bibliography
All-Story March 7, 1914 - The Eternal Lover - All All-Story Cavalier - January 23, 1915 - Sweetheart Primeval 1/4
The other three Sweetheart Primeval covers are displayed in our Pulp Biblio
on the ERBzine 0222 page

Paperback Covers



Ace reprint edition: Roy Krenkel cover artDel Rey edition: Michael Henning cover artPinnacle UK 1953 edition
Tandem edition UK 1976Japanese Motoichiro Takebe Eternal Lover


ROY G. KRENKEL ACE ART GALLERY
Visit our Krenkel ACE Galleries
I. ERBzine 3330 : Earth's Core and Moon
II. ERBzine 3331 : The Planets
III. ERBzine 3332 : Savage Earth

ark53h6.jpg
ACE F-234 | 1963
ark54h6.jpg
Frontispiece
ark55h6.jpg
Original
.

Alternate dust jacket using RGK art ~ created by Charlie Madison


 
THE ETERNAL LOVER
Review contributed by Doc Hermes ERB Reviews

This tale has Nu of the Niocene  (a sanitized caveman acceptable to our sensibilities) brought alive to the early 20th Century, where he indulges in the usual Burroughs shenanigans, falls in love with a Nebraska girl named Victoria Custer, tangles with African wildlife and eventually goes back somehow to his own time. The story first appeared in  ALL-STORY WEEKLY  in 1914, titled "The Eternal Lover" and "Sweetheart Eternal." Whoah. I can see why the editors at Ace decided to make a title change and go for the regular Burroughs fans but I sort of wish they had played this up as a romance. Keep the original title, have a cover featuring a Fabio-type dreamboat in furs, long hair and all, with young Victoria in modern clothes staring up at him adoringly. "He was like no man she had ever known," the cover copy would declare, "but could she trust her heart to this fierce savage from the dawn of time?" Then when the sales figures came back, the editors would weep and declare never again.

A few years ago, I cheerfully worked my way through the Tarzan series and found about half of them very good, the rest repetitious filler.  Before I got to the first book in the series, the reviewing frenzy left me (but then TARZAN OF THE APES has certainly been discussed enough over the last century). I didn't get to re-read this baby. Lord Greystoke does make a minor appearance here but he is very much in the John Clayton identity on his vast estate in Uziri land. So if you were looking for a typical Tarzan exploit, you'd be disappointed (although Nu certainly has his own wild, animal-slaying adventures). 

Many of ERB's early stories appeared in newspaper serial form.
Appearing with most of these serializations were new illustrations.




100th Anniversary of the Eternal Lover
By Robert Allen Lupton

Let’s take a look at what happened in the world of Edgar Rice Burroughs 100 years ago in October 1925. On October 3, 1925, A. C. McClurg published the first edition of THE ETERNAL LOVER. The story waited over ten years from its publication in ALL-STORY MAGAZINE before the book was published.


    All-Story published the two stories that became the novel. Part One, THE ETERNAL LOVER, was published in All-Story Weekly in the March 7, 1914 edition and Part Two, SWEERHEART PRIMEVAL, was serialized in All-Story Cavalier Weekly in four parts beginning on January 23, 1915 and concluding on February 13, 1915. Modest STEIN painted the cover  and Fred Small did a small black and white headpiece for THE ETERNAL LOVER and P. J. Monahan painted the cover for the first installment of SWEETHEART PRIMEVAL. More about the pulps later, back to the first edition.


The first edition cover was by J. Allen St. John, who else. The print run was only 5,000 copies in the common McClurg Blue Cloth binding. The book was reprinted regularly by Grosset & Dunlap. Ace Books reprinted the novel with cover art by Roy Krenkel during the 1960s Burroughs Boom, but changed the title to THE ETERNAL SAVAGE, believing the new title would be more appealing to fanboys.


The story established the beginning of THE EDGAR RICE BURROUGHS UNIVERSE, at least in my opinion. It’s what is referred to these days as a crossover novel. Tarzan and Jane appear briefly. The female protagonist, Victoria Custer, is the sister of Barney Custer, from THE MAD KING.  The story deals with reincarnation and eternal love, surprise. ERB regular wrote about various ways to achieve eternal or long life and this story is one of those. I especially enjoyed the idea that a soul has a single soulmate and that no matter how many times one is reincarnate, they’ll find that person again and again. H. Rider Haggard’s SHE and later Allan Quatermain novels explored similar themes.


Now to  return to the All-Story Weekly publications. The two installments of the novel shared the magazine issues with some well-known and not so well-known writers. There were a total of five issues, one for THE ETERNAL LOVER  and four for the serialization of SWEETHEARD PRIMEVAL.


The March 7, 1914 All-Story Weekly contained over a dozen other stories, mostly by writers largely forgotten. The exception is SECRETS by Rex Stout. The stories being serialized in that issue were THE DEVIL AND DOCTOR FOSTER by J. Earl Clauson, THE MAN WHO COULD NOT DIE by De Lysle Ferre Cass, THE SMOULDERING by Francis William Sullivan, and THE CASTLE ON THE CRAG by Stephen Chambers. Clauson authored a couple dozen stories and sold all of them to a Munsey magazine.  De Lysle Ferre Cass has eight pulp credits including OAHULA THE CARNIVOROUS (love the title). He is of ERB related interest as well for a Lost Race novel, involving Apes as Human encounters, which lay unpublished in the files of The Thrill Book until after his death, when it was discovered, it was believed to be by Clark Ashton Smith (despite bearing Cass's name), and published as AS IT IS WRITTEN  as by Clark Ashton Smith. Cass was only discovered to be the author after the book's release. Stephen Chambers authored over 100 pulp stories and founded the Stevenson Society (Robert Louis Stevenson) in the United States.


Francis William Sullivan, who wrote with the nom de plume Frank Williams, wrote TH WILDERNESS TRAIL, made into the film The Wilderness Trail starring Tom Mix. The story was originally published in Photoplay Magazine as GLORY ROAD and was followed by a sequel titled Star of the North. Two more of his novels were made into films, CHILD OF BANISHMENT and THE GODSON OF JEANETTE GONTREAU (THE FLAMES OF CHANCE – 1918).


    The issues that serialized SWEETHEART PRIMEVAL included the serializations of THE COASTS OF ADVENTURE by William Paterson White, a man from Tularosa, New Mexico and specialized in Westerns. He wrote over a hundred stories for the pulps.


<>        THE WEDNESDAY WIFE  by Juliette Gordon-Smith was also serialized in these issues. Gordon-Smith only had two pulp magazine credits, this one and “FORGOTTEN,” published in All-Story Cavalier Weekly in 1918.
 
        JUDITH OF BABYLON by Perley Poore Sheehan, who also authored what I would consider ERB pastiches, began in February 1915. The Kwa sequence, of which KWA OF THE APE PEOPLE was published in January, 1933 in THRILLING ADVENTURES  under the pseudonym, Paul Regard, springs to mind. THE LEOPARD MEN AND OTHER STORIES assembles the novel-length "The Leopard Man" (April-June 1932 THRILLING ADVENTURES and other similar tales published in the same magazine. Sheehan was also a director and screen writer and several of his novels were adapted for the screen.

Web Refs
ERB C.H.A.S.E.R. Online Encyclopedia
Hillman ERB Cosmos
Patrick Ewing's First Edition Determinors
John Coleman Burroughs Tribute
Novel Summary by James Bozarth
J. Allen St. John Bio, Gallery & Links
Edgar Rice Burroughs: LifeLine Biography
Bob Zeuschner's ERB Bibliography
J.G. Huckenpohler's ERB Checklist
G. T. McWhorter's Burroughs Bulletin Index
Burroughs Bibliophiles Bulletin
Illustrated Bibliography of ERB Pulp Magazines
Phil Normand's Recoverings
ERBzine Weekly Online Fanzine
ERB Emporium: Collectibles ~ Comics ~ BLBs ~ Pulps ~ Cards
ERBVILLE: ERB Public Domain Stories in PDF
Clark A. Brady's Burroughs Cyclopedia
Heins' Golden Anniversary Bibliography of Edgar Rice Burroughs
Bradford M. Day's Edgar Rice Burroughs: A Bibliography
Irwin Porges: The Man Who Created Tarzan

Armada of ERB Web Sites
Over 15,000 Webpages
The Fantastic Worlds of Edgar Rice Burroughs
Tarzan.com
Tarzan.com
ERBzine Weekly Webzine
ERBzine.com
Danton Burroughs Website: Tarzana Treasure Vaults
DantonBurroughs.com
Tarzan.org
Tarzan.org
Burroughs Bibliophiles
BurroughsBibliophiles.com
John Coleman Burroughs Tribute Site
JohnColemanBurroughs.com
Tarzine: Official Monthly Webzine of ERB, Inc.
Tarzan.com/tarzine
John Carter of Mars
JohnCarterOfMars.ca
Edgar Rice Burroughs
EdgarRiceBurroughs.ca
ERBzine Weekly Webzine
Weekly Webzine
Danton Burroughs Weekly Webzine
Weekly Webzine
Pellucidar
Pellucidar.org

John Carter Film News

ERB, Inc. Corporate Site

ERB Centennial

tarzana.ca
BACK TO ERB C.H.A.S.E.R. NAVIGATION CHART

BackForward
Volume 0759


BILL HILLMAN
Visit our thousands of other sites at:
BILL AND SUE-ON HILLMAN ECLECTIC STUDIO
All ERB Images© and Tarzan® are Copyright ERB, Inc.- All Rights Reserved.
All Original Work © 1996-2002/2013/2025 by Bill Hillman and/or Contributing Authors/Owners
No part of this web site may be reproduced without permission from the respective owners.