Erbzine.com Homepage
The First and Only Weekly Online Fanzine Devoted to the Life and Works of Edgar Rice Burroughs
Since 1996 ~ Over 10,000 Webpages in Archive
Volume 0828

The ERB Artist Profile Series
REX MAXON
Part 2
The Hal Foster Connection
See Part 1: Intro & Bio in ERBzine 0827


Rex Maxon and Turok Son of Stone
by Dale Broadhurst

Rex Maxon was almost certainly the co-creator of Turok. He evidently shared the first scripting work with comics professionals like Dell's editor, Matthew H. Murphy and Whitman's Paul S. Newman, but the characters Turok and Andar are direct parallels of the Young Hawk and Little Buck that Maxon drew for Dell's Lone Ranger comicbook throughout the 1950s.

Not only do Turok and Andar talk and interact very much like Young Hawk and Little Buck, but both sets of characters are brave, young plains Indians, living before the introduction of the horse in North America. Young Hawk and Little Buck are Mandan Indians, while Turok seems to be a Kiowa (or perhaps a Kiowa-Apache).

In the Aug.-Sept. 1958 issue of the Lone Ranger comic, there is a Young Hawk story in which the Mandans are walking through what later became New Mexico. In the following two episode, the braves take refuge in a great limestone cave (perhaps Carlsbad Caverns). The plotting of these sequences, all drawn by Maxon, is much like the story told in the first few panels of Maxon's Turok origin story. The 1958 Young Hawk episodes were published four years after the first Turok appearance, but earlier Young Hawk episodes contain similar tales which also parallel the some of the adventures of Turok and Andar. Young Hawk, in turn, was an evolution of Maxon's original Indian strip for the Lone Ranger comic: the Small Bear stories.

In the first story, Turok and his companion Andar venture into the "Lost Valley" of "the honkers," a strange, tropical world of the past. Their entrance into this lost world, through a vast limestone cave system, immediately calls to mind the 1932 (Hal Foster) story of Tarzan and Erik Von Harben, wandering through a similar underground maze, to the "primeval swamp" where dinosaurs still dwell upon the earth.

Artist Maxon no doubt savored this opportunity to tell once again the old United Features Sunday strip story, (which he himself would have drawn, had his position not been taken over by Harold Foster just a few months before). For years Rex Maxon's work on the Tarzan strip had been unfavorably compared with Foster's drawings and Maxon must have been well aware of that criticism. In laying out the first Turok story, Maxon had an opportunity to show how he might have illustrated the 1932 Tarzan pages, had he been retained on that challenging job twenty years before he went to work for Dell.

To his credit, Rex Maxon nowhere copies Foster's famous panels. The closest he comes to "swiping" from the master, is on page 14 of the origin sequence, where he shows the hump of the sauropod sticking out of the swamp water. The view is almost identical to what Foster delineated in 1932, but the remainder of Maxon's story is all an original demonstration of his own considerable talents.

Rex Maxon's work never contained the stylistic flair and intricate details that Foster brought to the comics page, but Maxon still managed to tell a visual story with a good understanding of what the reader needs to see. He is economical with his brushwork, rarely drawing much more than the minimum required to move the story along at a rapid pace. Maxon uses all the same tricks of camera angles, close-ups, distance shots, and strip "cinematography" that made artists like Foster and Caniff so well respected, but he does that in a low-key, unobtrustive sort of way. The reader does not stop to admire Maxon's draftmanship or his backgrounds, or his panel details in the same way that one might dwell upon a Foster scene for several seconds. Rather, the reader's eye moves from one Maxon panel to the next with an easy comprehension of the visual transitions. There is enough activity in a Maxon page to keep the story from becoming boring, but rarely does the reader see there the dramatic movements of a Foster or the frantic activity of a Hogarth.

Hal Foster's 1932 Tarzan panels would have been out of place in a Dell comic of the 1950s -- they are too colorful, too lush, too full of embellishment for the Eisenhower Era boys and girls, who knew that "Dell Comics" were "Good Comics" -- intriguing, easy to read, and full of clean fun. Maxon was in his element there -- in an environment where Foster would have been just "too much." Although their strip presentations were rather different, Rex Maxon's work at Dell was much like that of Jesse Marsh, in its simplicity and its story-telling. Both served as precursors to the Russ Manning style of drawing (and Manning was being a bit unfair when he faulted Maxon for spreading too much black ink through his 1930s Tarzan daily panels).

And, besides all of that, Foster's scarry, long-toothed dinosaurs would have been just a bit too much for Dell during the mid-50s. It was a time when "monster comics" were dying in a mass extinction and the editorial fingers at Dell must have been crossed when the company decided to bring out a "funny book" full of man-eating dinosaurs, without so much as a single Comics Code seal of approval gracing the cover of Turok's magazine. Turok was a success; it lasted far beyond the time of Mr. Maxon and later saw a rebirth as a somewhat modified "dinosaur hunter" epic during the 1990s.

On the other hand, a quick perusal of Maxon's Turok pages is probably enough for anybody to concur that it was best that he left the Tarzan Sunday stories to Foster and Hogarth. These artists benefitted from his path-breaking on the Tarzan page, but they then took the feature to new and breathtaking levels of visual excellence that were something other than simple Maxonish story-telling. And comparisons -- well, sooner or later they become odious. Apples and oranges, in this case. And, like apples and oranges, the Maxons and the Fosters of the comics world each have their place -- and each deserve to be savored for their own, special fulness and flavor.




 
Comparison of Two Illustrated Stories
1. Tarzan and Eric Von Harben in the "Primeval Swamp"
(Tarzan Sunday pages 9-25-32 to 10-30-32)
2. Turok and Andar in the "Valley of the Honkers"
(Dell Four Color Comics #596 - December, 1954)
 


Erik Von Harben and Tarzan ----- Turok and Andar
The hero and his companion (Erik, Andar) enter a great cave and at the cave mouth encounter flying creatures (pterodactyls / bats).



The adventurers explore a vast, underground cave system
While exploring the huge system of caverns the men find their way by their lights (flashlight / torches).
In the caves the explorers wander through huge underground galleries and are awe-struck with wonder at the sights.
Within the cave the explorers encounter a huge, menacing prehistoric creature (dinosaur / cave bear) but escape it.
The men follow an underground stream in hopes that it will lead them out of the maze of underground caverns.

They follow a river to a primeval world in a lost valley
They emerge into a great valley that contains primitive, tropical vegetation (primeval swamp / warm, steamy jungle)
The adventurers encounter the tracks of a huge, three-toed creature (the unknown terror / a dinosaur)


They find a strange island in the swamp water
In marshy jungle the men come across a strange, barren island that rises like a hump out of the swamp water.
The island seems to offer a safe resting place


The strange island turns out to be a submerged dinosaur
As the men approach the strange hump, a sauropod dinosaur rises out of the water, startling and confusing them
The first dinosaur does not seriously harm the explorers, but a second great reptile emerges from the jungle, threatening their lives


The dinosaur battles another great reptile
The men escape the second dinosaur also, and the two monsters engage in a deadly battle
Later the adventurers hide in a small cave to protect themselves from the dangerous, prehistoric beasts of the jungle
Before long the adventurers encounter a lost race of men, who both threaten them and aid them in various ways


The Origin of Turok
Dell Four-Color #596 (Dec. 1954)

Young Hawk excerpt from Lone Ranger comic #123 (Aug-Sept, 1958)
Young Hawk excerpt from Lone Ranger comic #123 (Aug-Sept, 1958)

From the Dale Broadhurst Collection

 
 

OTHER REFERENCE SITES
http://www.lambiek.net/maxon_rex.htm
http://www.erbzine.com/mag0/0044a.html
http://cagle.slate.msn.com/hogan/issue1/reviews.asp
http://dlib.lib.ohio-state.edu/cga/pdfs/201-300/0296.30.pdf
THE COMIC STRIP PROJECT
http://hometown.aol.com/comicsproj/creditsSZ.html
DREAM VAULTS OF OPAR
http://www.strangeexcursions.com/vaults/dvo-40.htm
Armstrong Sperry and Maxon
http://www.ogram.org/sperry/illustrator/tarzanlostempire/index.shtml
http://www.erbzine.com/mag3/0358.html
http://escena.ya.com/tarzana54/tnovedad.html
http://www.unitedmedia.com/comics/tarzan/archive/
Maxon's First Tarzan Sunday Page
ERB Foreign

THE REX MAXON TRIBUTE PAGES

I. Intro and Bio
II. Maxon/Foster Connection
III. Reprints
IV. Summary of Sunday Pages
V. Sunday Pages Thumbnails
Full-Size Sunday Pages I
Full-Size Sunday Pages II
Maxon Dailies


BILL HILLMAN
Visit our thousands of other sites at:
BILL & SUE-ON HILLMAN ECLECTIC STUDIO
ERB Text, ERB Images and Tarzan® are ©Edgar Rice Burroughs, Inc.- All Rights Reserved.
All Original Work ©1996-2006/2010 by Bill Hillman and/or Contributing Authors/Owners
No part of this web site may be reproduced without permission from the respective owners.